Involuntary euthanasia arguments essay - …
The Ethical Dilemma ESSAY
Euthanasia is a case sensitive controversial issue which can’t just be decided as a mater of just right or wrong, legal or illegal but each case needs to be examined thoroughly and justified individually.
EXAMPLE: Switzerland:assisted suicide has been legal since the 1940s and doesn't have to be performed by a doctor (active euthanasia is illegal...drugs may be provided but drugs must be administers actively by the patient)
Many countries and many peoples believe that helping someone die is wrong, others just believe making the act of assisting in death legal may lead to situations with suspect motives.
10 Arguments For Legalizing Euthanasia - Listverse
The decision to die by euthanasia will affect other people - our family and friends, and healthcare professionals - and we must balance the consequences for them (guilt, grief, anger) against our rights.We should also take account of our obligations to society, and balance our individual right to die against any bad consequences that it might have for the community in general.These bad consequences might be practical - such as making easier and so putting vulnerable people at risk.There is also a political and philosophical objection that says that our individual right to autonomy against the state must be balanced against the need to make the sanctity of life an important, intrinsic, abstract value of the state.Secular philosophers put forward a number of technical arguments, mostly based on the duty to preserve life because it has value in itself, or the importance of regarding all human beings as ends rather than means.
Someone who wants euthanasia will have already made this comparison for themselves.But utilitarianism deals with the total human happiness, not just that of the patient, so that even euthanasia opponents who agree with utilitarianism in principle can claim that the negative effects on those around the patient - family, friends and medical staff - would outweigh the benefit to the patient.It is hard to measure happiness objectively, but one way to test this argument would be to speak to the families and carers of people who had committed assisted suicide.Opponents can also argue that the net effect on the whole of society will be a decrease in happiness.